Oddities of the Russian election in Cyprus

Dmitri Khmelnitsky
Boris Demash
According to official reports, the election in Cyprus was a triumph for Putin. At two polling stations in Nicosia, one in the Russian Embassy and one in the so-called Russian House (the Rossotrudnichestvo office), a total of 53,000 people voted. Putin received 44,844 votes, which gives him 84% of all ballots issued. This is almost 10% more than the Russian average and slightly less than in Belarus (87.5%). A phenomenal success, according to official data.
But if you look closely at these figures, the picture is far less rosy and very interesting. Clearly the number of votes for Putin was set in Moscow and could not possibly be lower than the Russian average.
So, the first polling station, No. 8158, in the Russian Embassy.
Registered voters in total: 42,866. Of these, 36,870 voted early or using mobile ballot boxes. The total number of votes cast for Putin was 36,799. That is almost exactly the number of people who voted early and away from the polling stations. The difference is only 71 people.
Only 5,995 people actually came to the polling station in person. 739 of them, 12% of all who came, spoiled their ballots, that is, wrote on them what is not supposed to be written. If we add those who voted for Putin’s three rivals, we get 6,034 people. Practically the same as the total number who came to the station, only forty more.
Several conclusions follow. 70% of those who officially voted did so without coming to a polling station. Nobody saw them, and nobody monitored the voting. In other words, it can be said with a high degree of confidence that at least these 70% are dead souls. Their votes were stuffed. And they undoubtedly make up a huge share of the votes cast for Putin.
There is no reason to believe that the figures for those who actually voted at the station are accurate. But it can be assumed that people who wanted to vote against Putin came to the station rather than voting early or through mobile boxes. All the more so because at noon on 17 March the opposition gathered precisely at this station, in the Russian Embassy.

Polling station 8158 at the Russian Embassy in Nicosia
With ballot stuffing on such a scale through “mobile boxes”, there was no real need to tamper with the actual ballots. Even if this happened (which is more than likely), it would have involved hundreds or thousands of votes, not tens of thousands as with the mobile boxes. So the required share of votes for Putin at this station, 85.91% (!), was easily secured without touching the real ballots, even if every one of them had been against Putin. This does not, however, rule out falsification of the turnout. The fact that officially only one seventh of registered voters came to the station is already striking. In reality there were almost certainly far fewer. According to eyewitnesses, outside the embassy on the afternoon of 17 March, when people went to vote in response to the opposition’s call, the crowd was about a thousand people, who later dispersed.

The queue outside the Russian Embassy on the afternoon of 17.03.2024
The situation was different at the second station, No. 8439, in the Russian House. Strangely, according to the Central Election Commission, almost twice as many people came there as to the embassy.
Here 10,403 people were on the voter lists, and only two ballots were counted in mobile boxes. 10,381 ballots went into the stationary boxes. Of these, 951 were declared invalid, that is, deliberately spoiled, 9% of the total. Putin got 77.48%, or 8,045 votes. The other three candidates together got 1,387 votes. That is 3.8 times fewer than at the embassy station (5,295 votes), even though supposedly 1.7 times more people came to this station.
So at first glance one might assume that mostly Putin’s supporters came to this station, while his opponents went to the embassy. If, of course, one believes the official data. If not, the data shows very clearly how the manipulation worked.

Pro-Russian activists Nemsida Krupennikova and Christoforos Michaelides outside the Russian House in Nicosia, 16.03.2024
First, it is unclear why far more people would come to the Russian House than to the embassy. After all, the embassy is the symbol of Russian statehood for supporters and opponents of Putin alike. Second, the figures are absurd. If ten thousand people are spread evenly over all three days of voting (36 hours), the station would have had to let in almost five people a minute, or 278 an hour, the whole time. Yet according to eyewitnesses, there were no people at all near the Russian House on those days.
So the official voting data from both stations, the embassy and the Russian House, can safely be regarded as completely falsified, both the turnout and the distribution of votes.
The Cyprus result is interesting above all in comparison with other polling stations abroad. In London, for example, Davankov won with 53.07% of the vote, while Putin had only 21.05%. And 22.7% spoiled their ballots.
The picture was roughly the same in Spain, Portugal, Slovenia, Buenos Aires and many other places. In Berlin, 44% of voters voted for Putin, and 16.5% spoiled their ballots.
All this data shows, of course, not the real level of support for Putin among Russian citizens abroad, but how brazen the falsifiers were in the Russian embassies and consulates that ran the election. Here Cyprus is among the leaders, and it is well known whom it has to thank for that.
The Russian ambassador to the Republic of Cyprus, Murat Ziazikov, was praised for this by the deputy chairman of Russia’s Central Election Commission, Nikolai Bulaev. During a live link at a CEC briefing on voting abroad, Bulaev spoke highly of Ziazikov’s “brilliant” organisation of the election: “We are watching everything that is happening in the embassy [in Nicosia] and your work. There were certain fears that with so many people it would be hard to organise a proper vote. But it seems to me that your vast life experience, your energy, your persistence won over all the sceptics, and in fact the work on organising the vote today was done simply brilliantly. Many thanks to you for being able to overcome some resistance and misunderstanding here too, and for doing everything so that people could vote. Many thanks to you from the entire Central Election Commission.”
It must be said that Bulaev is largely right. Ziazikov really does have vast personal experience of the “proper” organisation of elections, going back to the time when, as an FSB general, he took his first steps in public politics.
Twenty-two years ago, in December 2001, the Kremlin forced General Ruslan Aushev, who was popular in Ingushetia, to step down early as president. A presidential election was called for 7 April 2002. Shortly before it, Moscow illegally removed the main contender for the post of head of the republic, Khamzat Gutseriev, then the republic’s interior minister, and put forward its own protégé, Murat Ziazikov, who was unpopular with the population. The whole republic declared a total boycott of the election. The elders of the Ingush people called on people not to take part. They also carried out a parallel count of those who voted and those who did not. According to their data, only 10% of voters came to the polling stations; 90% boycotted an election with a candidate imposed by Moscow.
The first round of the Ingush presidential election was won by a wide margin by Alikhan Amirkhanov, who received 33% of the vote. Ziazikov received 19%. According to the former president of Ingushetia, Ruslan Aushev, after the first round the political forces backing Ziazikov began to put heavy pressure on his rivals.
During the second round, the media reported mass ballot stuffing and police blocking polling stations in the districts where Amirkhanov had won the first round, so that people could not vote for him in the second. Those who still managed to get into the polling stations were handed ballots already ticked next to Ziazikov’s name.
In addition, the number of registered voters rose sharply, from 120,000 in the first round to 146,000 in the second. The magazine Kommersant-Vlast wrote: “Only those voters who had a holographic sticker in their passports, meaning that the holder was a supporter of General Ziazikov, were let through to the ballot boxes without hindrance.” According to the magazine, on election night the GAS Vybory system would not accept the results because there were too many stuffed ballots. In the end Ziazikov, who had lost the first round, still managed to get the votes he needed in the second (53.3% against Amirkhanov’s 43.9%).
The results of the 2024 Russian election in Cyprus, organised by Ziazikov, give no reason to believe that his methods have changed since then.
First published in Russian in Cyprus Daily News on 26 March 2024.


