Before the 2022 war, Cyprus was actively used by Russia as a platform for various propaganda campaigns and political provocations. One such provocation was an attempt in 2019 to set up, by a roundabout route, a representative office of Russian-occupied Crimea in Cyprus. The attempt failed, but thanks to a lucky turn of events numerous documents leaked online, allowing us to reconstruct the entire operation and understand the roles of those involved.
In June 2019, a poster exhibition entitled ‘Shrines of Chersonesos’ was held in the Cathedral of Limassol, Cyprus. It showcased Christian relics discovered during excavations at the Crimean Museum-Reserve ‘Tauric Chersonesos.’
As the organisers noted, the exhibition, which received the blessing of Metropolitan Lazar of Simferopol and Crimea, aroused ‘enormous interest among both Cypriots and our compatriots.’
At first glance, this exhibition appears to be merely a modest cultural event of a purely museum nature, albeit one of dubious legal standing. From an international legal perspective, the Tauric Chersonesos Museum-Reserve, a UNESCO World Heritage Site located in Russian-occupied Crimea, still belongs to Ukraine. As a result, UNESCO stopped monitoring the conservation of the museum-reserve in 2016.
This exhibition, organised by Russia, was essentially an exhibition of ‘trophy art’ it had illegally appropriated. However, the exhibition was a poster exhibition, meaning only images of the exhibits were displayed, eliminating the risk of their seizure should Ukraine file legal claims.
A closer look at the organisation and organisers of this event reveals a long-running political intrigue involving various pseudo-public organisations, Russian agencies, Orthodox hierarchs, and Russian intelligence agencies, which played a key role in this operation.
The exhibition's main organiser is Andrei Konstantinovich Ushakov, official representative of the Russian Nobility Assembly (RDS) in the Republic of Cyprus, leader of the Crimean Nobility Assembly (DSK), director of the ‘Cultural Heritage of Crimea’ Foundation for Cultural and Educational Programmes, and initiator of the ‘Friends of Tauric Chersonesos Club.’ The exhibition was also organised with the participation of the Foundation for the Support of Humanities and the Tauric Chersonesos State Museum-Reserve, located near Sevastopol.
A small digression is required here.
Immediately after the collapse of the USSR, countless front ‘scientific,’ ‘social,’ and ‘charitable’ organisations, most of them backed by the KGB, began to spring up in Russia. They distributed their own ‘public’ orders and titles in Russia and abroad, hosting gala receptions, often under the auspices of Russian embassies, consulates, and cultural centres. There are dozens, if not hundreds, of such organisations in Russia. On the one hand, they prey on vain and ignorant individuals who buy their comical ‘public’ orders and titles of nobleman, academician, professor, doctor, colonel and general. On the other, they function as branches of the secret services: they host international events where they distribute their awards to the right people, thus making contacts and recruiting. They are also usually run by people from the secret services. As a rule, such outfits have unclear sources of funding (which in itself provides clarity) and very pompously and pretentiously stated goals.
The Russian Nobility Assembly undoubtedly falls into this same category of state front organisations masquerading as public bodies. Its website states: ‘In its activities, the Russian Nobility Assembly pursues cultural and educational goals aimed at reviving Russia's greatness... the faith of our ancestors and the historical traditions of Russian statehood... the establishment in Russia of true culture... traditions of faithful service to one's Fatherland... high morality and spirituality.’ This is the typical meaningless, chauvinistic, and anti-democratic language of state security, which rather poorly disguises the traditional goals of Soviet and Russian intelligence agencies.
The Russian Nobility Assembly consists of 51 regional branches in Russia and 13 branches and representative offices abroad.
The Crimean Nobility Assembly was created in 2015, after the occupation of the peninsula, as a regional branch of the RDS and registered in early 2016. Its leader from the very beginning was Andrei Ushakov, a man with a rather curious biography.
According to information on the DSK website, Andrei Konstantinovich Ushakov was born on February 8, 1972, in Moscow and studied at the Physics Department of Moscow State University from 1989 to 1994. He apparently did not graduate from university, and since 1995, he has headed the Commonwealth Expert Information Service group of companies, which serves as the secretariat for the Russian Olympus Prize.
This strange company organised programmes under the names ‘Russian Construction Olympus,’ ‘Reliable Organisations in the Construction Sector,’ ‘Russian Energy Olympus,’ and ‘Russian Financial Olympus.’ The programmes selected ‘enterprises and companies occupying leading positions in economic sectors. In a celebratory atmosphere, the winners are presented with public awards demonstrating their high professional competence.’
In 2005, Ushakov held an international forum in Cyprus with the apt title ‘Investment Attractiveness of Russian Regions,’ which included the distribution of ‘Russian Olympus’ awards. That same year, the ‘Ukrainian National Olympus,’ ‘Ukrainian Financial Olympus,’ and ‘Ukrainian Construction Olympus’ programmes were established.
In 2009, the ‘Russian Olympus’ programme in the financial sector was renamed ‘Golden Phoenix.’ In 2011, this ‘group of companies’ organised a conference in Geneva with the exotic title ‘Experience and History of Self-Regulation in Western European Countries.’ Simultaneously, the 15th anniversary of the ‘Russian Olympus’ award was celebrated there, and its laureates were awarded.
According to Andrei Ushakov himself, he worked and lived in Cyprus and Switzerland. In 2014, after the annexation, he returned to Crimea, as he puts it, ‘in connection with the reunification with Russia of new regions – the Republic of Crimea and the city of Sevastopol.’ Since Russia's seizure of Crimea, Ushakov has been working in Crimea, where he set up another organisation with the exotic name ‘The Unified Expert and Information Centre of Crimea and the City of Sevastopol.’
In 2015, when the Crimean branch of the Russian Nobility Assembly was created, Ushakov was elected leader of the Crimean nobility.
On his initiative, the foundation for cultural and educational programmes ‘Cultural Heritage of Crimea’ was also created, the goal of which is the restoration of cultural heritage sites of the Crimean peninsula and the development of culture and art.
‘With funding from the Crimean Cultural Heritage Foundation, a number of internationally significant events were carried out between 2016 and 2019, contributing to the strengthening of Crimea's positive image and objective information about the legality and historical validity of its return to Russia.’
The last sentence reveals the real purpose of the foundation: KGB-style propaganda. Ushakov's work history lacks even a hint of a formal profession and, at first glance, looks completely absurd. At second glance, it reveals many years of undercover intelligence work directed abroad. And in this sense, it is typical.
Another organiser of the exhibition, the ‘My History’ Foundation for the Support of the Humanities, was registered in Moscow in May 2014, two months after the annexation of Crimea and most likely in connection with it. It is a non-profit organisation created ‘to implement programmes to support projects in the cultural and educational spheres.’ The foundation's primary focus is Tauric Chersonesos. Its partners include the Presidential Grants Fund, Gazprom, the Moscow Patriarchate, the Russian ministries of education and culture, and the governments of various Russian cities. In other words, the foundation is openly governmental.
The main goal of the exhibition in Cyprus was clearly formulated in a letter from the acting director of the Tauric Chersonesos Museum-Reserve, E. A. Morozova, to the official representative of the Russian Nobility Assembly in Cyprus, Andrei Ushakov, dated February 1, 2019:
‘We welcome the opportunity to jointly implement cultural projects aimed at providing objective information about the legality and historical validity of Crimea's return to Russia.’ According to plans published on the DSK website, the exhibition in Cyprus was supposed to take place in January 2019. More precisely, the ‘House of Crimea in the European Union’ cultural centre was supposed to open in January in Cyprus, and its activities would have begun with the exhibition.
The reasons for the creation of the ‘House of Crimea in the European Union’ are described in detail in a letter from the Deputy Chairman of the Council of Ministers of the Republic of Crimea, Georgy Muradov, to Ushakov.
‘The measures imposed by Ukraine and EU countries against Crimean residents, which contravene international law and restrict the freedom of movement of Crimean residents, the de facto blockade of cultural and kinship ties between Crimean ethnic communities, and the ban on transport links, tourism, and business ties with Crimea, are clearly discriminatory and illegal. <…> Under these circumstances, the initiative of Crimean public representatives to create a permanent venue for internationally significant cultural, informational, and business events in the Republic of Cyprus, which maintains friendly ties with Russia, including exhibitions, concerts, creative meetings, and master classes by Crimean cultural institutions and figures, appears relevant and promising.’ This letter, in fact, outlines the goal of the entire operation. It was necessary to breach the European Union and force at least one of its members, if not legally, then indirectly, to recognise Russia's annexation of Crimea.
The cultural, historical, and religious aura surrounding the activities of the leader of the Crimean nobility in Cyprus was merely a disguise. Christian holy sites were not at issue here.
‘The “House of Crimea in the European Union” will open in January 2019 with the exhibition “Shrines of Chersonesos”, created by our long-standing friends and partners, the Tauric Chersonesos Museum-Reserve, specifically for this event,’ states the ‘House of Crimea in the European Union’ section on the DSK website.
The exhibition's creators and organisers expressed hope that it would be ‘a wonderful Christmas gift for residents and visitors of Cyprus, stimulating interest in the unique archaeological heritage of Chersonesos and awakening a desire to visit the cultural and religious centre in person.’
Furthermore, the explanatory note to the project states that the ‘House of Crimea in the EU’ is being created on the premises of the official representative office of the Russian Nobility Assembly in Cyprus, ‘where internationally significant cultural and business events will be held on a permanent basis, contributing to the strengthening of Crimea's positive image.’
‘The “House of Crimea in the European Union” will undoubtedly become a meeting place for citizens of other countries to learn about the culture of the peoples of Crimea and to discover the peninsula's key spiritual, historical, and tourist attractions. To this end, the newly established office will host regular exhibitions, concerts, creative meetings, and master classes by cultural institutions and figures from the Republic of Crimea and the city of Sevastopol. We have already collaborated with a number of Russian and international organisations regarding the creation of the “House of Crimea in the European Union” and have received positive feedback from all,’ the description states.
The plans for the future cultural centre in Cyprus were ambitious: an exhibition titled ‘Shrines of Chersonesos’ would be held in January, and a multimedia exhibition titled ‘Crimea in the Fate of Russia’ would be held from February to April, with daily screenings in Russian, Greek, and English. Weekly multimedia exhibitions about prominent figures connected to the Crimean peninsula were also planned.
A visit to the ‘House of Crimea in the EU’ by the famous traveler and priest Fyodor Konyukhov and a concert programme ‘Crimea in the Musical Art of Russia’ with the participation of Crimean musicians, dancers, opera and ballet artists were announced.
Roundtables and conferences on various topical issues were planned throughout 2019. It was also announced that, as a result of the activities of the ‘House of Crimea in the EU’ in Cyprus, a ‘Friends of Crimea Club’ would be established, which would include ‘compatriots living abroad, Russian and foreign citizens who share an interest in the Crimean Peninsula.’ Reciprocal events were also planned on the Crimean Peninsula, with the participation of members of the ‘Friends of Crimea Club,’ which would help ‘finance joint programmes,’ according to the Nobility Assembly's website.
However, at some point, the future ‘Club of Friends of Crimea’ was wisely renamed the ‘Club of Friends of Tauric Chersonesos.’ The organisers invited international and Russian companies, charitable foundations, and individuals to participate in the club's activities.
In an interview with a Cypriot Russian-language portal, Ushakov explained the reasons for registering the Friends' Club in Cyprus:
‘We decided to register it because if it were registered in Sevastopol, it would not be able to be international due to sanctions, and the entire purpose of the association would be lost. It will be supported by private funds from patrons.’
In the same interview, Andrei Ushakov reported that ‘a project has been prepared by the members of the club's board of trustees,’ whose activities are aimed at optimizing the museum's financial strategy, attracting investment, and ensuring its effective use.
It was assumed that international companies, charitable foundations, and individuals would use Cyprus to attract investment and optimize the financial strategy of the Ukrainian museum, which, following the annexation of Crimea and its transfer to Russian ownership, received Russian state funding.
The planned composition of the board of trustees of the ‘Friends of Crimea Club’ in Cyprus turned out to be very interesting.
The co-chairs are Elena Morozova, director of the Tauric Chersonesos Museum-Reserve, and MGIMO graduate Georgy Muradov, Russia's ambassador to Cyprus from 1996 to 1999, deputy prime minister of occupied Crimea, and, presumably, a key figure in the entire operation. His details have already been discussed above.
The list of alleged trustees of the ‘Friends Club’ also included Russian Ambassador to Cyprus Stanislav Osadchiy, Russian Honourary Consul to Cyprus Georgios Prodromou, Orthodox businessman Vyacheslav Zarenkov, Alexey Voloboev, founder of the ‘Russian Party’ in Cyprus, ‘Ego o Politis,’ Yuri Pyanykh, President of the Association of Russian Businessmen in Cyprus, Haris Trassou, President of the Cyprus-Russia Friendship Society, and unnamed representatives of the Cyprus Leventis Foundation, the Cypriot Orthodox Church, and the Russian Orthodox Church. All of these names have already been mentioned above. Therefore, it can be concluded that the board of trustees of the ‘Friends of Crimea Club’ in Cyprus was intended to consist of Russian officials, Cypriot ‘friends of Russia’ simulating independent socio-political activity, and Russian intelligence agents disguised as representatives of both groups.
However, this grandiose project was never fully realized. At some point, after the ‘House of Crimea in the EU’ project was renamed the ‘Club of Friends of Tauric Chersonesos,’ it was reworked and significantly scaled back. The exhibition was postponed until June 2019. Crimean artists, films, multimedia exhibitions, and roundtable discussions never made it to Cyprus.
On the eve of the ‘Shrines of Chersonesos’ exhibition, information about the ‘House of Crimea in the European Union’ project leaked to the Cypriot press, labeling it a Russian intelligence operation. Former Ukrainian Ambassador to Cyprus Borys Gumenyuk responded to the leaked information in the Cypriot newspaper Cyprus Mail. In his article, ‘The Russian-Crimean “Trojan Horse” in Cyprus,’ he described it as Moscow's ‘clumsy’ efforts to prove that Crimea, one way or another, belongs to Russia.
Although the Russian press claimed the Crimean exhibition had generated ‘tremendous interest,’ attendance was, in fact, more than modest. The leader of the Crimean Nobility Assembly even had to publicly defend himself:
‘Interest in the project, oddly enough, was expressed by the Cypriot side, in particular the Cyprus Diocese, and interest was also shown by museum workers and ordinary parishioners.’
In fact, it was the Russian side that showed interest in the Cyprus ‘project’, and much earlier. In the same interview, Mr. Ushakov also stated that the Russian Nobility Assembly, of which he is a board member, cooperates with the Russian Orthodox Church, and in particular with the Moscow Patriarchate. ‘Therefore, before holding this exhibition, we received approval from the Metropolitan of Volokolamsk,’ Ushakov said, ‘as well as the blessing of Metropolitan Lazar of Simferopol and Crimea.’ Moreover, the Metropolitan of Volokolamsk specifically noted that he considers it important to ‘avoid any political context when organising this event.’
It's worth noting that the exhibition, which was scheduled for January 2019, was approved in March, postponed to April, and was held only in June.
Here is a quote from the Crimean Nobility Assembly's report, posted on its website, which states that ‘as a result of a visit to the Republic of Cyprus in December 2018, an agreement was reached with the Cypriot Orthodox Church to hold a series of exhibitions in the Republic of Cyprus in 2019 about the holy places of the Crimean Peninsula and to direct tourists from the Republic of Cyprus to the Crimean Peninsula along pilgrimage routes.’
So the first to show interest were not Cypriot museum workers, parishioners and priests, as the leader of the Nobility Assembly would have it.
In the aforementioned interview, Ushakov insistently convinces readers that the Crimean event in Cyprus ‘is purely cultural and educational in nature,’ that it is not propaganda, but rather organised solely to share the peninsula's cultural heritage with the island. Because the museum is a UNESCO World Heritage Site and belongs to the entire world.
Andrei Ushakov also emphasised that there is no connection between the project and ‘the actions of the intelligence services or Putin,’ or the Russian government. Try proving otherwise...
In this sense, it is interesting to pay attention to the chronology of the preparation of the ‘House of Crimea in the EU’ project.
On May 8, 2018, the 12th International Festival ‘Great Russian Word’ was held in Yalta. DSK Chairman Andrei Ushakov presented a report on the feasibility of establishing a cultural centre, ‘House of Crimea in the European Union,’ in Limassol, Cyprus, based at the official representative office of the Russian Nobility Assembly.
In the fall of 2018, from October 31 to November 1, the VI World Congress of Compatriots was held in Moscow under the slogan ‘Russia and Compatriots: New Challenges and New Frontiers.’ The DSK press release stated that the Republic of Crimea was represented at the congress by Georgy Muradov, Permanent Representative of the Republic of Crimea to the President of the Russian Federation; Andrei Ushakov, Chairman of the Crimean Nobility Assembly; and Pavel Shperov, State Duma Deputy. The same release also stated:
Andrei Ushakov discussed with representatives of the Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs the prospects and details of establishing a cultural centre, the ‘House of Crimea in the European Union,’ at the official representative office of the Russian Nobility Assembly in the Republic of Cyprus. Participants in the discussion noted that the ‘House of Crimea in the EU’ could become a reliable platform for implementing Russia's state policy in the EU and make a significant contribution to the international community's recognition of the Republic of Crimea and the city of Sevastopol as full-fledged and legitimate subjects of the Russian Federation.
The information does not indicate with whom exactly from the Russian Foreign Ministry the prospects and details of creating the ‘House of Crimea in the EU’ were discussed, but the discussion was apparently representative.
On November 24, 2018, a general meeting of the DSK members was held in Crimea. Andrei Ushakov reported on the organisation's activities over the past three years. The meeting considered proposals from DSK members to create a department of culture and a department for interaction with public organisations and government agencies. The proposed structure for interaction with government agencies within the public organisation more closely resembles the structure of a government department.
Two days after the DSK reporting and election meeting, the official representative of the RDS in Cyprus, Andrei Ushakov, flies to the island.
On November 26, 2018, he held a working meeting with Russian Ambassador Stanislav Osadchiy at the Russian Embassy in Cyprus. ‘During the meeting, the parties discussed the project to establish the “Cultural Centre of the Russian Nobility Assembly in the Republic of Cyprus” and a plan for joint cultural and artistic events for 2019,’ according to a statement on the DSK website.
Following the meeting, Andrei Ushakov, along with Russian Embassy staff, visited the Russian Cultural Centre, where he held talks with its director, Alina Radchenko. ‘The talks focused on holding a number of significant events during 2019–2020 under the auspices of the Russian Nobility Assembly. Agreements were reached to hold a series of exhibitions, concerts, and creative meetings at the Russian Cultural Centre.’
In December 2018, during a visit to the Republic of Cyprus, Ushakov agreed with the Church of Cyprus to hold exhibitions ‘about the holy places of the Crimean Peninsula’ and to direct tourists from Cyprus to the Crimean Peninsula along pilgrimage routes.
In honour of the 900th anniversary of the establishment of spiritual ties between Russia and Cyprus, the official representative office of the Russian Nobility Assembly in Cyprus also developed a pilgrimage route, ‘Orthodox Shrines of Cyprus. From Byzantium to the Present Day.’
On February 21, 2019, Andrei Ushakov participated in the 1st Ushakov Forum. The Imperial Orthodox Palestine Society (IOPS) was among the forum's co-organisers. ‘Forum delegates received greetings from Sergei Lavrov, Honourary Member of the IOPS and Russian Foreign Minister; Sergei Naryshkin, Director of the Foreign Intelligence Service and Chairman of the Russian Historical Society; and from the Synodal Department of the Moscow Patriarchate for Cooperation with the Armed Forces.’ Sergei Stepashin, co-chair of the forum's organising committee, Chairman of the IOPS and former Director of the FSB, also spoke at the forum.
At that very time, correspondence was underway with the hierarchs of the Russian Orthodox Church regarding approval for an exhibition in Cyprus. In the letters the planned exhibition was still called ‘Shrines of Crimea’; it was finally renamed only closer to summer.
Thus, it can be argued that the initiative to create a permanent venue—the ‘House of Crimea in the EU’—for cultural, informational, and business events originated with the highest echelons of the Russian government. The project was developed over a year, but was only partially implemented—a single exhibition.
Cyprus was also not chosen by chance. Everything was taken into account: the local population's friendly attitude toward Russia, their shared religion, the unique national character of the Cypriots, the large number of Russian speakers living in Cyprus, the local authorities' loyalty to Russia, and much more. It would be hard to find a better location in Europe for a Russian-Crimean ideological intervention.
The project failed, but the mechanism for its preparation and implementation is typical of many other operations of this kind.
