In October 2019, a very interesting event took place in Limassol, Cyprus: the International Conference on Media Participation in Countering Terrorism. It was organised by the International Academy of Television and Radio (IATR) with the support of the Federal Agency for Press and Mass Communications of Russia and the Union of Journalists of Cyprus. Kaspersky Lab was the conference's general partner for information security.
The topic itself seems odd. Countering terrorism is, to put it mildly, not the job of the press. Furthermore, when an international conference on countering terrorism is hosted by a country whose government is directly involved in terrorism, it raises a reasonable suspicion that the stated topic is a disguise for something entirely different.
In any case, the murders and attempted murders of known opponents of the Putin regime—Litvinenko and the Skripals in London, Khangoshvili in Berlin, and so on—do not, as is well known, fall under the definition of ‘terrorism’ from the Russian authorities' perspective. They refuse to assist with investigations, and Litvinenko's killer, Andrei Lugovoi, sits in the State Duma.
The actual meaning of the announced topic will be discussed below. First, it's worth taking a closer look at the organisers and participants of the conference, which, according to the announcement, brought together ‘well-known Russian journalists and experts, representatives of foreign electronic media, diplomatic missions, and law enforcement agencies.’
As mentioned above, numerous charlatan academies, simulating scientific and social activity, emerged in Russia in the 1990s. Many of them primarily made their living by selling comical titles and their own home-made orders, while simultaneously carrying out missions for the secret services. That is, they foisted these same awards on foreign politicians, military personnel, and other important people, thus establishing contacts. But some academies were specifically created for intelligence and diplomatic purposes under the guise of social activity.
The International Academy of Television and Radio (IATR) undoubtedly belongs to the latter group.
According to its website, the academy ‘was established in October 2002 at a founding conference of representatives of electronic media from Azerbaijan, Armenia, Belarus, Georgia, Canada, Lithuania, Russia, the United States, Finland, Tajikistan, and Switzerland. By decision of the founders, the IATR headquarters are located in Moscow. In 2004, the IATR was registered by the Ministry of Justice of the Russian Federation as an international organisation. Currently, the academy comprises over 300 television, radio, and internet professionals from 26 countries on four continents.’
The academy's website lists 202 full members, but there are almost no foreigners among them. Either there are no foreigners in reality, or there are reasons to conceal their names.
The president of the IATR until his death in 2021 was Anatoly Lysenko, the former head of the All-Russian State Television and Radio Broadcasting Company and, according to people who knew him, a KGB colonel during the Soviet era.
The list of official partners of the IATR includes Rossotrudnichestvo, Kaspersky Lab, the Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs, and the Federal Agency for Press and Mass Communications, followed by various Kremlin-backed media organisations: Public Television of Russia, Ostankino, the Russian Television and Radio Broadcasting Network, the Union of Journalists of the Russian Federation, and so on. There are no foreign organisations on the list.
This list alone makes it clear that the academy is a purely governmental entity, linked to the intelligence services and focused on foreign activities.
Kaspersky Lab is a company affiliated with the FSB. Kaspersky himself graduated from the KGB Academy. Back in 2017, the US Department of Homeland Security issued a directive prohibiting federal agencies from using Kaspersky-branded products in their information systems. Since September 2024, the sale of Kaspersky products has been completely banned in the US.
Rossotrudnichestvo is an offshoot of the Russian intelligence services that deals with emigrants. The line between the Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the Russian intelligence services is rather vague.
The international activities of the IATR began in 2005 with the presentation of an honourary diploma to the Mayor of Toronto. Perhaps the academy was created specifically to host conferences such as this one. The first conference, ‘Terrorism and Electronic Media,’ was held in 2005 in Gelendzhik, Russia. The next seven were held in Cyprus. In 2013 the conference took place in Budva, Montenegro; in 2014 in Baden, Austria; in 2015 in Dagomys, Russia; in 2016 in Belgrade, Serbia; in 2017 in Sofia, Bulgaria; and in 2018, again in Cyprus. The 2019 conference in Limassol was the fifteenth. From 2020 to 2022, they were held in Moscow. Apparently, Cyprus proved the most convenient location for these purposes.
It's very interesting to look at the list of speakers at the Limassol conference. The most prominent group consisted of high-ranking former KGB-FSB officers, whose affiliation with these agencies is disguised in the programme by their civilian or administrative positions.
Vladimir Kozlov, co-chair of the conference organising committee and deputy head of the Federal Agency for Press and Mass Communications of the Russian Federation, spoke at the opening of the conference.
Lieutenant General Vladimir Kozlov, a graduate of the Dzerzhinsky Military Academy and the Red Banner KGB Institute, began his career in the KGB in 1978. From 1994 to 1995, Kozlov served as Deputy Chief of the Special Operations Directorate of the Federal Counterintelligence Service of Russia (FSK RF). In 1995, the FSK was renamed the FSB, and Kozlov seemingly changed his profession, becoming Deputy Minister of the Russian Federation for Press Affairs. He has held this position since 2005. It is clear that Kozlov's work has nothing to do with the media in the strictest sense, but rather with mass disinformation.
Valentin Sobolev, Chairman of the Board of Directors of the Military Insurance Company ‘Life Line,’ is Kozlov's colleague from the same service, but of even higher rank.
Colonel General Sobolev is a graduate of the KGB Higher School. He served in the state security agencies since 1972. From 1994, he was deputy director of the FSK, and from 1999, first deputy director of the Federal Security Service of the Russian Federation, overseeing counterintelligence activities. From 1999 to 2008, he was deputy and then acting secretary of the Security Council of the Russian Federation. He is an honourary counterintelligence officer.
The highest-ranking KGB-FSB officer among the conference participants was Nikolai Bordyuzha, introduced as the vice president of the International Lighting Corporation ‘BOOS LIGHTING GROUP.’ However, nothing in Bordyuzha's biography indicates a connection to the lighting fixture manufacturing industry, which his corporation is officially engaged in.
Colonel General Bordyuzha graduated from the KGB Higher Courses for Military Counterintelligence in Novosibirsk and began his service in 1976. In 1998, Bordyuzha became vice president of the international lighting corporation BOOS LIGHTING GROUP. From 1998 to 1999, he served as Secretary of the Security Council of the Russian Federation and simultaneously as Chief of Staff of the Presidential Executive Office, replacing Valentin Yumashev. According to rumors, Bordyuzha was considered a possible successor to Yeltsin. From 1999 to 2003, he served as the Russian Ambassador to Denmark. From 2003 to 2016, he served as Secretary General of the Collective Security Treaty Organisation, a military organisation of the CIS countries.
Alexander Mikhailov, a member of the Council on Foreign and Defence Policy of Russia, also belongs to this professional group.
Colonel Alexander Mikhailov served in the state security agencies since 1973. From 1982, he served in the KGB's Alpha Special Forces Group. He fought in Afghanistan and in the First and Second Chechen Wars. In 2002, he led the group that stormed the Dubrovka Theatre, which had been seized by Chechen terrorists. He ended his service as a department head in Directorate A (Alpha) of the FSB Special Forces Centre. However, on the website of the organisation ‘Officers of Russia,’ where Mikhailov is the head of the Central Executive Committee, he is listed as a police lieutenant general.
Such a concentration of FSB counterintelligence generals at a murky conference with an absurd name awakens interest in the other participants, primarily foreigners.
The most important of these is George Frangos, the official co-organiser of the conference and head of the Cyprus Union of Journalists. A year earlier, in November 2018, Frangos signed a cooperation agreement in Moscow between the Cyprus Union of Journalists and the Russian Union of Journalists. Simultaneously, similar agreements were signed by the heads of the journalists' unions of Poland, Uzbekistan, South Korea, Abkhazia, and Mongolia. Under the current circumstances, such agreements clearly indicate successful recruitment by the Russian side.
At the opening of the conference, Frangos read a greeting from the President of Cyprus, and at the closing session, he reiterated the President's invitation to hold the next conference in 2020 in Cyprus. A couple of weeks before the conference, Frangos had a friendly meeting in Cyprus with Sergei Gorbachev, a representative of the Sevastopol branch of the Union of Journalists of Russia (also not a journalist, but a military man). Such contacts are extremely important for Moscow: they break the international isolation of Russian-occupied Crimea.
The group of foreign participants includes two Israelis: Vladimir Beider and Raya Koval. Both are Soviet émigrés.
Vladimir Beider, who immigrated in 1995, has headed the propaganda department of the Yisrael Beiteinu party since 2014. Raya Koval, an immigrant since 2006, organises conferences and international projects at the Jerusalem Press Club.
Back in 2015, Spaniard José Luis Barceló, director of the newspaper El Mundo Financiero, participated in a video conference organised between the editorial office of Parlamentskaya Gazeta in Moscow and the Russian Centre for Science and Culture in Madrid. The discussion focused on condemning the EU's sanctions policy in connection with the occupation of Crimea. Barceló lamented that the sanctions were a major setback for the EU and expressed support for Russia's position.
Italian Tiberio Graziani is an old friend of Russia, which in this context means ‘an old agent of influence.’ He is introduced in the conference programme as ‘Chairman of the International Institute of Global Analytics (Italy).’ Such pompous titles, with their pretensions to ‘globalism,’ are typical of sham pseudo-scientific outfits backed by Russia and the KGB. Graziani is the founder (2004) of the Italian journal ‘Eurasia,’ whose first issue featured an introductory article by Alexander Dugin. Vladimir Yakunin and Alexander Prokhanov were among the journal's contributors. In 2011, Graziani began publishing the journal ‘Geopolitika,’ whose scientific board included Natalia Narochnitskaya.
In 2013, Graziani, as president of the Institute for Advanced Studies in Geopolitics and Related Sciences (IsAG, Italy), and Narochnitskaya, as president of the Paris Institute for Democracy and Cooperation (another obvious front organisation with KGB roots), held a conference in Rome titled ‘Russian-European Cooperation: Current Situation and Development Prospects.’
The names of the foreigners featured in the conference programme are listed above. Other participants included representatives from ‘Belgium, Belarus, Greece, Israel, Spain, Italy, Cyprus...’
The third group of conference participants included representatives of the management of state-run Russian media outlets (OTR, RT, Rossiya-1) and leading pro-Kremlin journalists. The most important figure among the latter was apparently Leonid Mlechin, an international journalist dating back to Soviet times. Back then, such a status automatically meant close ties to state security. Mlechin had been the chairman of the IATR board since 2013, and in 2021, following Lysenko's death, he became its president.
The most interesting thing about this conference is its purpose. Why was it necessary to gather together, especially in Cyprus, counterintelligence generals, foreign agents of influence, and Kremlin media officials? The official conference theme, ‘Media Participation in Countering Terrorism,’ as already noted, clarifies nothing and sounds absurd. But some insights can be gleaned from the conference's final document.
It says:
‘…the conference participants draw the attention of all journalists to the following questions:
1. How can professional journalism maintain audience trust in the age of fake news?
2. How can we mobilise the resources of bloggers and YouTubers to combat terrorism and hate propaganda?
3. Are there new ways for the media, diplomats, and security agencies of different countries to cooperate in the fight against terrorism?’
The funniest question is the first one, especially considering it comes from the very people generating the fakes—representatives of the official Russian press, whose reputations have long been hopelessly ruined. On the other hand, these people are genuinely interested in making their fakes appear credible. Presumably, the conference was about how to make fakes look plausible.
At first glance, the second question is completely absurd. It is quite unclear what is meant by ‘terrorism and hate propaganda’ in this case. The conference participants' speeches may provide some clarity. In his opening remarks, Russian Ambassador to Cyprus Osadchiy stated that in the modern world, ‘social media is widely used as a trigger for all kinds of color revolutions and mass unrest.’
Colonel Alexander Mikhailov, speaking at the previous conference in 2018, expressed his opinion equally clearly: ‘At the conference, much attention was devoted to social media and how to work with it. You must admit, we don't know how to counter social media. They're a battlefield right now, and we're not even present on it. And prohibitive measures without active intervention on social media itself are useless... It's important not to fight technology, like an Inquisition, but to develop ideological, political, and moral filters.’
So, the conference participants' main enemy is social media, which they currently lack significant influence over. Osadchiy's reference to ‘color revolutions and mass unrest’ fueled by social media is a reference to the 2013 Ukrainian revolution and the anti-Putin protest movement in general.
Mikhailov, meanwhile, calls for countering social media by introducing ‘ideological, political, and moral filters.’ Enough is known about the political views and moral principles of Russian intelligence agencies and Putin's professional propagandists to be certain that what's at issue here is the intensification of fake propaganda and troll activity on global social media. This was probably one of the most important topics the participants actually discussed, though hardly in public.
The third question—about ‘cooperation between the media, diplomats, and security agencies of different countries in the fight against terrorism’—is no less absurd than the others. Or rather, the answer has long been known. Only it doesn't refer to ‘different countries.’
No diplomats or intelligence officers other than Russian ones were present at the conference. Cooperation between Russian diplomats and intelligence agencies and the press is only possible through the recruitment of editors and journalists. Recruiting new agents is one of the main tasks of the active agents of influence gathered at such conferences. Undoubtedly, this issue was also actively discussed in the close circles of those gathered.
In this context, the phrase ‘counterterrorism’ takes on a clear meaning. It's a fight against any anti-Putin protests and the strengthening of fake Russian propaganda. Labeling all opponents of the Putin regime as terrorists is one of the most widely used fakes by the current Russian government. In Russia itself, this practice had already become a widespread form of repression by 2019, with people receiving long-term prison sentences for peaceful political protests. Promoting this narrative in the international press requires mass recruitment of foreign journalists and anyone else deemed useful to the security services. This is precisely why conferences like these are held.
The fifteenth IATR conference in 2019 was also noteworthy because it was held in Cyprus for the ninth time. Montenegro, Austria, Serbia, and Bulgaria hosted the conference once each, and Russia hosted it twice. This means that the conference organisers enjoyed particularly strong and friendly high-level government ties in Cyprus. Furthermore, the high-ranking Cypriot officials participating in the conference clearly knew who they were dealing with and what they wanted.
The background is as follows. The first, pilot IATR conference was held in 2005 in Gelendzhik. ‘It was attended by over 130 journalists and experts from 18 countries. It was then decided to make this forum an annual event.’ The second conference was held in 2006 in Ayia Napa, Cyprus. Gelendzhik and Ayia Napa only became sister cities in 2017 (confirming their ties with joint celebrations in 2023), but the contacts that allowed IATR to begin its expansion into Cyprus from Ayia Napa apparently existed even then.
In Ayia Napa, General Valentin Sobolev, Deputy Secretary of the Russian Security Council, complained that ‘due to weak censorship, easy access, the presence of a huge potential audience and anonymity, the Internet is becoming increasingly important in the activities of extremists and terrorists,’ and called for ‘joint work between the media and the intelligence services.’
From 2006 to 2012, the annual IATR conferences were held in Cyprus—and for good reason. From 2001 to 2008, the Speaker of the House of Representatives of Cyprus was Dimitris Christofias, head of the AKEL Communist Party of Cyprus. In 2008, Christofias was elected president, a post he held until early 2013. Throughout these years, Christofias was Moscow's main partner in Cyprus.
Dimitris Christofias was born in 1946. From 1969 to 1974, he studied in Moscow, graduating from the Institute of Social Sciences under the CPSU Central Committee, where he later defended his PhD dissertation. This is Christofias's only higher education, but it can only be called higher in the specifically Soviet sense.
The Institute of Social Sciences under the Central Committee of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union (ISS) trained cadres for legal and illegal communist movements in both the First and Third Worlds, including militant saboteurs. After graduating from the ISS, Christofias quickly rose through the ranks of the AKEL party, becoming its leader in 1988. His wife, Elsie Chiratou-Christofia, also studied at the ISS (they married in Moscow in 1972) and was also an AKEL functionary and a member of its Central Committee.
As Cypriot journalist Makarios Drousiotis writes in his book Putin's Island, ‘Christofias was the first fully pro-Russian president in the history of Cyprus. Even though the Russian regime had become oligarchic and had abandoned the country's communist past, for Christofias, Russia remained the “mother country”. Christofias never tried to hide his adoration of Russia: “I consider myself one of those people who consider themselves friends of Russia. We, Cypriots who studied in Russia at different times, have felt throughout our lives a sincere love and gratitude for this great country and its people, as well as admiration for its rich culture and heroic history.” The Russian government invited Christofias to Moscow in November 2008. Christofias considered his return to Moscow as President of the Republic of Cyprus one of the most important moments of his life. During a joint press conference with Russian President Dmitry Medvedev, Christofias, almost in tears, spoke of his studies in the Soviet Union, which he said shaped his political personality, and thanked AKEL and the Communist Party of the Soviet Union, whose relations had initially brought him to Moscow… Christofias defended Russia's interests even when they conflicted with those of Cyprus, following the same dogma that the Soviet Union imposed on its satellite communist parties, a dogma that placed the interests of international communism above the national interests of states.’
In 2014, now as a private citizen, Christofias stated at a meeting in Moscow with Sergei Aksyonov, head of the government of occupied Crimea: ‘I support the people of Crimea, who have restored their rights and returned to their home – Russia. I have no doubt that Crimea will sooner or later receive international recognition. Right now, unfortunately, European governments are making decisions, of course, under the guidance of the United States.’
Christofias's patronage ensured the Moscow guests most-favoured-nation treatment. As the IATR website proudly announced: ‘Since 2007, at the suggestion of the President of the Republic of Cyprus, Dimitris Christofias, Honourary Chairman of the Conference, Cyprus has become the permanent venue for these conferences.’
The third IATR conference was held in Limassol in October 2007. It was attended by ‘eighty journalists and representatives of law enforcement agencies from 18 countries, including Israel, India, France, Morocco, Tunisia, Serbia, Croatia, Lebanon, and Greece.’ When asked by a journalist why Cyprus was chosen as the venue, General Nikolai Bordyuzha responded frankly: ‘We saw this as a very interesting and convenient platform for discussing critical issues related to international security. Israel, Arab countries, and Europe are nearby. The Republic of Cyprus was once subjected to aggression. For over 30 years, part of its territory has been annexed by a NATO member. This location on the Mediterranean is very convenient for people representing various political groups, often opposing, and various media outlets with different views on current events and issues, including those related to the fight against terrorism.’
In other words, Cyprus is extremely conveniently located for Russian intelligence agencies, making it a great place to invite people who, for various reasons, would find it difficult to travel to Moscow. Conferences held in such a convenient and neutral location are ideal for meeting with established agents and recruiting new ones.
The fourth conference, ‘Terrorism and Electronic Media,’ was held in October 2008 in Paphos. President Christofias attended its opening at the House of Journalists in Nicosia. Anatoly Lysenko presented him with the International Academy of Radio and Television's medal ‘For significant contribution to the development of television and radio at the national or international level.’ There were approximately 100 participants—journalists, experts, and government officials from more than 25 countries, including Russia, Cyprus, Greece, Spain, Germany, and India.
The fifth conference was held in October 2009 in Ayia Napa. ‘It was attended by journalists, intelligence officials, and experts from 27 countries, as well as a number of international organisations—the CSTO, the OSCE, the Council of Europe, the Arab League, and the International Confederation of Journalists' Unions.’ It was reported that ‘the Russian delegation was received by the President of Cyprus, Dimitris Christofias.’ Unfortunately, neither the programmes of this or other conferences nor the lists of participants have been published.
The main conclusion of this conference is curious: ‘The time has come to create a united international front to combat terrorism through the combined efforts of journalists, psychologists, sociologists, and representatives of the intelligence services,’ and to concentrate the work on the IATR website, which ‘will play a coordinating role between all conference participants in the intervals between conferences.’
In other words, the idea was to create a new international ‘non-governmental’ organisation based on the IATR, led by Russian intelligence services. Essentially, a new spy network. Perhaps this was the original intent. And, most likely, the goal was achieved.
In November 2010, President Christofias opened the sixth conference in Nicosia; the conference itself was held in Limassol. More than 70 participants from 23 countries attended. Also present were Russian Ambassador Shumsky and Cypriot Justice Minister L. Loukas.
The seventh (2011) and eighth (2012) conferences were also held in Limassol, and they were also opened in Nicosia by President Christofias. Participants were welcomed both times by the President of the Cyprus Union of Journalists, Antonis Makridis. In 2012, the Cypriot government spokesman, Stefanos Stefanou, addressed the conference.
The fact that four conferences (2007, 2010, 2011, 2012) were held in Limassol can also be explained by the fact that Andreas Christou, the mayor of Limassol from 2007 to 2016, a graduate of the Moscow Automobile and Road Construction State Technical University (MADI), an AKEL party functionary and a member of the experts' club at the Russian Centre of Science and Culture in Nicosia, was also no stranger to the Moscow guests.
In 2013, Dimitris Christofias did not run for president, and until 2018, conferences were held in other European countries with a climate favourable to the activities of Russian intelligence services – Montenegro, Austria, Serbia, Russia, and Bulgaria.
It was only in November 2018, following Nicos Anastasiades' reelection as president, that the fourteenth conference was held in Cyprus, again in Limassol. General Vladimir Kozlov, Russian Ambassador Stanislav Osadchiy, and George Frangos, President of the Cyprus Union of Journalists, spoke at the opening ceremony at the House of Journalists in Nicosia. Deputy Government Spokeswoman Klelia Vasiliou delivered a welcome address on behalf of Cypriot President Nicos Anastasiades, who proposed holding the next, fifteenth conference in 2019, also in Cyprus. And so it was. Participants included ‘Russian and foreign journalists, international experts, intelligence officials, and representatives of international and public organisations from Belgium, the United Kingdom, Greece, Israel, Italy, Jordan, Cyprus, Macedonia, Russia, Romania, Serbia, and France, as well as representatives of the diplomatic missions of Egypt, Qatar, Oman, the UAE, Syria, and France.’
The 2020 conference planned in Cyprus at the invitation of President Anastasiades was cancelled due to the COVID-19 pandemic. In 2022, following Putin's attack on Ukraine, diplomatic relations between the EU and Russia were frozen, and direct air traffic was suspended. Open contacts, such as group and individual visits to Cyprus by Russian intelligence generals, became impossible. Under these circumstances, the secret contacts with Cypriot friends and agents, developed over decades and still in place, take on even greater significance.
***
Interestingly, simultaneously with the IATR's expansion in Cyprus during the same years (2007–2019), a very similar operation was carried out in Germany. It also involved numerous intelligence generals, but under the guise of scientific rather than public activity.
A certain pseudo-scientific organisation – the Institute of Information Security Problems (IISP) at Moscow State University – chose the Bavarian resort town of Garmisch-Partenkirchen to host its international conferences in 2007.
The main actor in this performance is the director of the IISP, Colonel-General Vladislav Sherstyuk (b. 1940). He graduated from the physics department of Moscow State University and served in the KGB from 1966, where he had, to put it mildly, a successful career. From 1995 to 1998, he headed the Main Directorate of Electronic Intelligence of Communications of FAPSI. FAPSI is the Federal Agency for Government Communications and Information under the President of the Russian Federation. It was created in 1991 and incorporated the former 16th Directorate of the KGB, which was renamed the Main Directorate of Electronic Intelligence of Communications (GURRSS, or 3GU). Sherstyuk served there from 1992. Since 1998, Sherstyuk has been the deputy general director of FAPSI and simultaneously the head of the same Main Directorate of Electronic Intelligence of Communications.
From December 1998 to May 1999, Sherstyuk was the general director of FAPSI and a member of the Security Council of the Russian Federation. From May 1999 to May 2004, he was the first deputy secretary of the Security Council of the Russian Federation (in 1999, Putin, who replaced Bordyuzha, briefly served as secretary of the Security Council). Since September 2004, Sherstyuk has been an assistant secretary of the Security Council of the Russian Federation.
Then, General Sherstyuk suddenly became an academic. In 2003, an organisation called the Institute of Information Security Problems (IISP MSU) was created within Moscow State University as a subdivision. In a 2019 interview, Sherstyuk himself mentioned that in 1999, at the behest of Putin, then Secretary of the Security Council, he ‘engaged in science.’ As a result, a department and then an institute were established at Moscow State University, and ‘the Garmisch Process grew from there.’ As stated on the institute's website, ‘IISP is the lead structure coordinating interdisciplinary research activities within Moscow State University in the field of 'Security and Counterterrorism.'’
It should be noted that the term ‘counter-terrorism’ in the names of Russian organisations or press outlets almost unmistakably refers to the activities of the KGB, represented by its numerous subsidiaries that emerged in the 1990s.
Sherstyuk's deputies are two colonels from the Federal Agency for Government Communications (FAPSI). Since 2007, the institute has held annual international forums in Garmisch-Partenkirchen, Germany, entitled ‘Partnership between the State, Business, and Civil Society in Ensuring Information Security and Countering Terrorism.’ Business and civil society are mentioned here only for the sake of concealment, while the state is represented by high-ranking officials of the Russian intelligence services.
What's even more piquant is that Garmisch-Partenkirchen is home to an American military base and the George C. Marshall European Centre for Security Studies, whose representatives also participated in the forums until 2014. After the occupation of Crimea, they stopped.
The keynote speakers at the conferences are Russian generals and intelligence officers, representatives of the Russian Security Council and the Russian Foreign Ministry, and some strange foreigners.
As Andrei Soldatov writes in his book ‘The Red Web: The Struggle Between Russia's Digital Dictators and the New Online Revolutionaries’ (2015), in the early years, the US sent high-ranking representatives to Garmisch-Partenkirchen in hopes of reaching an agreement with the Russians, who were resentful of the US role in internet governance. Convincing them that these were purely technical issues proved unsuccessful.
They couldn't even agree on the meaning of the word ‘internet.’ The negotiations reached a dead end. As one American participant put it after the 2010 conference: ‘The Russians have a completely different definition of information security... what they really mean is state security.’ In other words, since about 2010, these conferences have lost their international diplomatic significance, retaining only intelligence and recruitment purposes. It also shows that the participants' motives had nothing to do with science.
In 2010, at the fourth IISP forum, a typical intelligence stunt was pulled: another front organisation, ostensibly new and scientific, was created: the ‘International Information Security Research Consortium’ (IISRC). The declaration of its creation was signed on behalf of Moscow State University by V. Sherstyuk, Director of the Institute of Information Security Problems at Moscow State University, along with representatives from the National Academy of Sciences of Belarus, the Bulgarian Internet Community, the State University of New York, Tokai University in Japan, and the Israeli Government's Department of Information Security.
Since then, the IISP and IISRC forums have been held jointly. Specifically, in April 2016, the 13th IISRC conference and the 10th IISP forum were held simultaneously in Garmisch-Partenkirchen. The IISRC meeting was chaired by Colonel General Sherstyuk. At the opening, a greeting from Deputy Secretary of the Russian Security Council S. M. Buravlev was read. Before taking up that post, Colonel General Sergei Buravlev had been Deputy Director of the FSB from 2005. Buravlev had worked in state security since 1971.
The following speakers spoke at the meetings: A. V. Krutskikh (Special Representative of the President of the Russian Federation for International Cooperation in Information Security); Major General I. N. Dylevsky (Deputy Chief of the Main Operations Directorate of the General Staff of the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation); A. A. Soldatov (Chairman of the Supervisory Board of the Internet Development Fund); M. V. Yakushev (Vice President of ICANN (the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers) for Eastern Europe and Central Asia); V. I. Gasumyanov (Vice President and Head of the Corporate Security Unit of Norilsk Nickel).
All of these are people from the special services.
In 2018, the organisers pulled another trick. A brand-new organisation, NAMIB (National Association for International Information Security), emerged from nowhere to take over the organisation of conferences in Garmisch-Partenkirchen. The previous president, General Vladislav Sherstyuk, remained, as did the presidium members, who retained their familiar names. The 13th Garmisch-Partenkirchen Forum, ‘Partnership between Government, Business, and Civil Society,’ was held in April 2019 under the auspices of NAMIB. As reported, over 100 participants from 18 countries attended the 2019 forum.
And here, to put it mildly, a bit of an embarrassment arose. The NAMIB website published an article titled ‘Russia and Germany Agree on Cybersecurity Cooperation,’ with a link to ‘Russkoe Pole’ (Russian Field), a Russian propaganda site based in Germany. It proudly published a memorandum of cooperation signed by an FSB colonel general on one side and a German politician with sufficient visibility and connections to raise eyebrows among journalists and concerns among the government on the other.
This was brought to the attention of the German press: the newspaper Die Zeit and the ARD television magazine Kontraste. This happened only thirteen years after the beginning of the annual conferences for this audience in Garmisch-Partenkirchen.
In General Sherstyuk's interview at the conference's closing, an interesting remark was made: ‘Today, to our delight, our German colleagues have finally joined this effort. It took 12 years. We hope that starting this year, they will become partners in this whole endeavor.’ This phrase implies that they hadn't yet managed to recruit any influential Germans, and now they've finally succeeded. The quote also makes it clear that Sherstyuk considers his German partner a colleague.
Sherstyuk's colleague was Hans-Wilhelm Dünn (born 1978), a regional politician at the CDU in Potsdam, the capital of Brandenburg, and president of the non-governmental organisation Cyber Security Council of Germany (Cyber-Sicherheitsrat Deutschland e.V., CSRD). The organisation includes many large German companies, such as Airbus, Commerzbank, and Volkswagen. The publication of the memorandum (clearly not intended for the attention of the German press) caused shock among journalists and politicians for several reasons. The name of the organisation Dünn leads is strikingly similar to that of a government body, the National Cyber Security Council (Nationaler Cybersicherheitsrat). When signing the memorandum, Dünn dropped the ‘e.V.’ at the end of his organisation's name, the letters that mark it as a registered association rather than a government body. Former President of the German Federal Intelligence Service (BND), Gerhard Schindler, drew attention to this sleight of hand in an interview with Kontraste. Many might have assumed that General Sherstyuk signed the memorandum with a major agency, bringing together representatives from all federal ministries, rather than a public organisation. According to Schindler, this entire story closely resembles a typical Russian influence strategy, and it is the National Cyber Security Council that should take action, as information security is crucial for protecting the population.
Another important point: Dünn's predecessor as President of the German Cyber Security Council until 2016 was Arne Schönbohm, who served as President of the Federal Office for Information Technology Security until the end of 2022. Dünn's contacts opened up dazzling prospects for the Russian generals.
Journalists discovered that other members of the organisation led by Dünn (CSRD) were not informed of the memorandum being signed on their behalf. This prompted Sebastian Fiedler, chairman of the Criminal Police Association (BDK), to demand Dünn's resignation under threat of the BDK withdrawing from the CSRD.
It also emerged that Dünn had observed the Russian presidential election in March 2018, not as part of the OSCE mission, but at the invitation of the State Duma Speaker, along with representatives of various right-wing pro-Russian European parties, including the Alternative for Germany (AfD). His reaction to the conduct of the Russian elections, however, was more than favourable.
Six months later, Dünn was an observer at the presidential elections in Zimbabwe, but again not for the European Union, but for the little-known organisation AFRIC (Association for Free Research and International Cooperation), with anonymous funding and, according to an investigation by Die Zeit and Kontraste, linked to Russian propaganda experts.
After the Garmisch-Partenkirchen memorandum scandal erupted, on June 20, 2019, Dünn attended the International Cybersecurity Congress in Moscow, where he called for an immediate ‘dialogue on international law and cybersecurity.’
***
Both operations—in Cyprus and Germany—are very similar in their organisers, goals, and methods. Apparently, they were carried out as part of a common tactic of creating new intelligence networks. The fundamental difference between them is that in Germany, the Russian generals failed to recruit any more or less prominent German politicians into their work. And just when such success seemed imminent, a scandal erupted, ending the operation, hopefully forever.
In Cyprus, intelligence conferences have been held from the very beginning with the participation and support of the Cypriot political elite at the highest level. And nothing will prevent these conferences from resuming when they become physically possible again.
